Broker Check

What Is the Best Order to Withdraw From Retirement Accounts to Minimize Taxes?

By James Mehok, Investment Advisor Representative with Private Advisor Group and founder of Mehok Wealth Management.

The best order to withdraw from retirement accounts to minimize taxes depends on your income needs, pensions, Social Security, account types and tax situation. Address required distributions first when applicable, then compare a coordinated mix of taxable, traditional and Roth withdrawals. There is no single tax-efficient order that fits every retiree.

When I work with a client, I compare withdrawal choices within their financial plan. I want to understand how a decision affects the income they can spend today and the assets they may rely on 10 or 15 years from now. Paying the least tax this year is not always the best long-term plan.

Why taxable first, traditional IRA next and Roth last is not a universal rule

The familiar account sequence can be a useful starting point, but it leaves out the timing of your other income. Someone receiving a substantial pension presents a different planning situation from someone relying primarily on savings before Social Security begins.

I start with the income the client needs, subtract the income already coming in, and compare how different accounts could meet the remaining need. Sometimes that means using more than one account type during the same year rather than exhausting one account before touching another.

If you need an introduction to the account types, read which accounts can fund your retirement income. Here, the focus is how taxes and the timing of income can change the withdrawal decision.

What should you review before choosing a retirement withdrawal order?

Before making a recommendation, I begin by checking the facts. A projection built on incomplete information can make a strategy look more suitable than it is.

  • Spending needs, including taxes and larger planned purchases.
  • Pension payments and their taxable portion.
  • Whether Social Security has started or is still being considered.
  • Employment, business, investment and other income.
  • Account balances, tax treatment, cost basis and withdrawal restrictions.
  • Required minimum distributions, when applicable.
  • Medicare enrollment and potential income-related premium adjustments.
  • Filing status, applicable state taxes, fees and the assumptions used in the plan.

For someone retiring before age 59½, early-distribution rules and possible exceptions also need review. Access to an account does not mean a withdrawal will be free of additional tax. Employer-plan and inherited-account rules may require a separate analysis. The IRS explains IRA distribution rules in Publication 590-B.

How do taxable, traditional and Roth accounts affect the calculation?

Taxable brokerage accounts: the withdrawal is not necessarily the taxable gain

When you sell an investment, the capital gain or loss generally reflects the difference between sale proceeds and adjusted cost basis. Taking $10,000 of sale proceeds does not automatically mean recognizing $10,000 of taxable income. The holdings sold and their cost basis matter.

Some long-term capital gains may qualify for a 0% federal rate, depending on taxable income and filing status. Ordinary taxable income uses part of the income range available before gains move into a higher capital gains rate. This is one reason I compare potential IRA withdrawals with investment sales rather than assuming taxable accounts must always come first.

A 0% federal capital gains rate does not mean the gain is absent from the tax return. It can still affect income-based calculations, and state tax treatment may differ. See the IRS explanation of capital gains and losses.

Traditional IRAs: consider both voluntary and required withdrawals

Traditional IRA distributions are generally taxable to the extent they represent pre-tax amounts. Previously taxed contributions can change the calculation. When required minimum distributions apply, those obligations belong in the plan before deciding how to meet the rest of the spending need.

Delaying voluntary withdrawals can preserve tax deferral today, but it may leave a larger balance subject to future required withdrawals. Whether taking some income earlier makes sense depends on the comparison, not an assumption that earlier withdrawals are always better.

Roth IRAs: flexibility depends on the distribution rules

Qualified Roth IRA distributions are tax-free. Qualification requirements, including applicable holding-period and age rules, matter. A nonqualified withdrawal can have different consequences.

Qualified Roth withdrawals may provide flexibility when an additional taxable withdrawal would have unwanted effects. Preserving every Roth dollar indefinitely is not automatically the right choice either. The IRS describes these distinctions in its IRA distribution guidance.

How can a pension or Social Security change the recommendation?

A recurring situation in my work is the client who has a large pension. That income may cover much of their spending, but its taxable portion also becomes part of the tax picture we need to work around. The amount of additional income we can introduce has to be evaluated in that context.

For a client without a large pension, the years after work ends may look different from the years after Social Security or required withdrawals begin. I compare those periods instead of treating retirement as one unchanging income level.

Additional income can also increase the portion of Social Security benefits subject to tax. That means the tax effect of an IRA distribution can extend beyond the distribution itself. The IRS explains how Social Security benefits are evaluated for taxation.

Remaining in the same ordinary income tax bracket does not mean a withdrawal has no additional tax cost. Ordinary income brackets, capital gains rates, Social Security taxation and Medicare thresholds are related considerations, but they are not the same calculation.

Can retirement withdrawals increase Medicare premiums?

Higher-income Medicare beneficiaries may pay an income-related monthly adjustment amount, or IRMAA, for Part B and prescription drug coverage. Social Security generally uses tax information from two years earlier to determine the adjustment. This deserves attention before Medicare starts as well as after enrollment.

In my planning work, I want to know whether a proposed withdrawal or conversion could create an additional premium cost. Receiving Social Security is not a prerequisite for IRMAA; Medicare coverage and the relevant income calculation are what matter.

Taxable IRA income, the taxable portion of a Roth conversion and realized gains can affect that income calculation. Even gains taxed at a 0% federal capital gains rate can matter. A qualifying life-changing event may permit a request to use more recent income information, but a reduction is not automatic. Review Social Security's Medicare premium guidance.

Avoiding an IRMAA threshold should not become the only objective. We still need to consider spending, future taxes and the overall plan.

Should you withdraw from a traditional IRA or convert to Roth in lower-income years?

That is a comparison worth making, not a recommendation that applies to everyone. A withdrawal used for living expenses and a Roth conversion serve different purposes. A conversion moves assets to a different tax treatment, and its taxable portion generally creates income in the conversion year.

I compare income and taxes before and during retirement. I do not assume a conversion before retirement is always better. The analysis includes the cash available to cover taxes, potential Medicare effects, future required withdrawals and the client's priorities.

When required minimum distributions apply, the required amount cannot itself be converted to a Roth IRA. Review the IRS distribution and conversion rules and our discussion of Roth conversion planning.

What does a 10- to 15-year withdrawal comparison show?

When I present alternatives, we look at withdrawal amounts and percentages alongside their effect on the overall nest egg. A recommendation becomes easier to understand when clients can see the relationship between the income they need and the assets expected to provide it.

We may compare a familiar fixed account order with a coordinated approach using more than one account type. I want the comparison to show current spending needs, potential taxes, Medicare costs where relevant, future withdrawals and remaining investable assets under the assumptions used.

The point is to make the tradeoffs visible. A lower tax bill in the first year may not produce the more suitable outcome over the full period. Conversely, paying more tax now does not automatically improve the future result.

Investment returns, inflation, fees, spending, tax rules and the timing of withdrawals can change the projection. A financial model illustrates possible outcomes under stated assumptions. It does not establish a guaranteed tax saving, investment return or future account balance.

How do I coordinate a withdrawal strategy with your CPA?

When the proposed approach involves Roth conversions, I want the client's CPA involved in reviewing the plan. We can compare the planning assumptions with the tax professional's calculations and identify questions before implementation.

My role is to connect the recommendation with the client's overall financial plan and explain the next steps. The CPA evaluates the relevant tax treatment within their professional role. The client should receive a clean explanation of what we are considering, why it may fit and who is responsible for each part.

That coordination is part of the service. It helps avoid treating a withdrawal or conversion as an isolated transaction.

Questions clients ask about tax-efficient retirement withdrawals

Should I empty my taxable account before using my IRA?

Not automatically. Compare the taxable gains from selling investments with the effect of IRA distributions on current and future income. A combination may fit better than completely exhausting one account type.

Is taking money from a Roth IRA always the best way to avoid taxes?

Qualified Roth distributions are tax-free, but the lowest immediate tax cost is only one consideration. Future flexibility, other account balances and your overall retirement needs also matter.

Does a 0% capital gains rate mean the sale has no other tax consequences?

No. A realized gain may still affect Social Security taxation, Medicare's income calculation or state taxes. The capital gains rate is one part of the analysis.

How often should I revisit my withdrawal strategy?

Review it when income, spending, account requirements or tax rules change, and before a significant withdrawal or conversion. The strategy should stay connected to the financial plan rather than become a permanent instruction.

Bring your withdrawal question to a conversation

You do not need to arrive with the account order already figured out. Start with the income you need and the question that feels least clear.

Explore retirement planning, tax-aware financial planning and connecting savings with a retirement paycheck, or request a conversation with James Mehok. Phone and video meetings are available, and Crown Point meetings are by appointment.

The first discovery meeting is free and lasts approximately 30–60 minutes. We discuss your situation and priorities; no recommendations are made at that first meeting. Services are subject to applicable registration requirements and the agreed scope of the engagement.

Return to Blog & Insights.

Important disclosures

This material is for general educational purposes and is not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances, and tax laws may change. Consult qualified tax and legal professionals before implementing a strategy. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Asset allocation and diversification do not guarantee a profit or protect against loss. Financial planning and projections do not guarantee results. Roth conversions may create current tax liabilities, and qualified Roth distributions are subject to applicable requirements.

Securities offered through LPL Financial, Member FINRA/SIPC. Investment advice offered through Private Advisor Group, a registered investment advisor. Private Advisor Group and Mehok Wealth Management are separate entities from LPL Financial.

Prepared for review November 5, 2026. Official sources checked November 5, 2026. This draft is subject to James's review and applicable compliance approval.

Private Advisor Group Form CRS