Flat Fee vs. Percentage Wealth Management: How to Compare Costs

Compare the relationship, not just the rate

When you are deciding how to pay for financial advice, a flat dollar fee and a percentage of assets can look difficult to compare. Start with the work you need, then ask what each proposal would cost in dollars. Neither pricing structure, by itself, establishes the quality of advice or the best fit for your situation.

This educational guide explains common arrangements. It is not a Mehok Wealth Management fee schedule or an offer of either pricing model. Available services, fees and terms must be confirmed through the applicable agreements and disclosures.

What does a flat fee mean?

A flat fee sets a dollar price for a defined service or period. It might cover a one-time planning project or an ongoing engagement. Confirm what is included, when payment is due, whether the fee can change and what additional work would cost. A fixed price for planning alone is not directly comparable to a price that also includes managing investments.

How does a percentage-of-assets fee work?

An asset-based advisory fee applies a rate to specified assets. Ask which assets count, how their value is measured and how often fees are calculated and billed. Some schedules use tiers or minimum fees. An annual rate is not a quarterly rate, and a tiered schedule may require more than multiplying the entire balance by one percentage.

With an unchanged rate and no minimum, the dollar fee generally changes as the billed assets change. That can reflect deposits and withdrawals as well as investment gains or losses. It is not necessarily a fee based on investment performance.

A simple dollar comparison

Assume two hypothetical proposals cover exactly the same services: a $6,000 annual flat fee or a 1% annual asset-based fee. If the billed balance stayed at $400,000 all year, 1% would equal $4,000. At $600,000, it would equal $6,000. At $1 million, it would equal $10,000.

In this simplified illustration, the point where the advisory fees match is $6,000 divided by 0.01, or $600,000. These are invented figures, not Mehok Wealth Management rates, market averages or a recommendation. They exclude other costs and assume no tiers, minimums, balance changes or fee changes. Actual billing can produce different results.

For your own comparison, request written dollar estimates using your current balance and the same services. Then ask how the estimate would change after a substantial withdrawal, a new deposit or a change in the work required.

What do you receive for the fee?

Build a checklist around the help you want. For someone preparing to retire, useful questions might include:

Does the engagement include a retirement income plan as well as investment management?
Who reviews Social Security decisions and the timing of withdrawals?
What coordination with my tax and legal professionals is included?
How are meetings arranged, and what happens when my circumstances change?
Are implementation, monitoring and updates included, or separately priced?

Do not assume these services are included because of the fee label. Ask for the scope in writing and compare the responsibilities of each party.

Look beyond the advisory fee

Your total cost can also include investment fund expenses, transaction charges, account or platform charges and separately billed services. Ask which charges are included in the quoted price and which remain additional. Avoid counting an included charge twice. Fees and expenses reduce the money available to remain invested, so their effects matter over time.

Understand incentives and disclosures

Neither model eliminates conflicts of interest. An asset-based arrangement can create an incentive to increase assets subject to the fee. A flat arrangement still warrants questions about the services delivered, additional charges and other compensation.

The way a fee is calculated is a separate question from whether commissions or other compensation are received. Do not infer compensation sources or the applicable standard of conduct from a flat-fee or percentage label. Review Form CRS, the applicable advisory brochure and agreements, and ask how conflicts are addressed. LPL Financial and Private Advisor Group Form CRS links appear in this website's footer.

Five questions to bring to a conversation

What would I pay in total dollars, including costs outside your fee?
What services, accounts and assets does the proposal cover?
How can the amount change, and are there minimums?
How are you and your firm compensated, and what conflicts should I understand?
What happens if I end the relationship or no longer need a service?

A useful comparison makes both the cost and the relationship easier to understand. Review the answers alongside your planning needs rather than choose solely from a headline rate.

Start with your goals and questions

James Mehok works with individuals, families and business owners on retirement, investment and broader financial priorities. Your free discovery meeting lasts approximately 30–60 minutes and focuses on understanding you and your goals; no recommendations are made at that first meeting. James responds to requests within one business day to arrange a time. Phone and video meetings are available, with Crown Point meetings by appointment only.

Request Your Free Discovery Meeting

Explore services for individuals and families or call (219) 400-0485.